Why writers should never work with committees

Why do things that happen to       examine this dichotomy in our
stupid people keep happening       nature.
to me? - Homer Simpson             In seeking insight, perhaps
Committees are the bane of my      we can find  better ways to
existence. Even though I know      come to grips with our
that much of the work of the       differences.
world would never get done         For almost 50 years, Kurt
were it not for the stalwarts      Vonnegut was perceptive and
who volunteer to sit on            profound, and funny in
committees and boards, I feel      exposing humans to who we are
particularly justified in          and how we operate.
making this particular             As a prisoner of war in
statement, since I have            Dresden, Germany,  during
volunteered to sit on way too      World War II, Vonnegut
many committees in my life,        witnessed the bombing
especially in the years            devastation of the city. He
before my current marriage.        knew what he talking about.
You needed a seat filled, I        Cat's Cradle was originally
was there, baby, no questions      published in 1963; it is as
asked.                             apropos today as it was in
And many boards and                the midst of the cold war.
committees do a lot of             The first sentence of Cat's
valuable work. But some? Well,     Cradle conjures up another
I am reminded of the Babylon       literary opening. "Call me
5 episode in which two             Jonah. My parents did, or
warring nations of a planet        nearly did. They called me
erupt into battle every few        John."
years over a trivial issue.        From that moment on, Vonnegut
There have ben steps made to       plunges into a dark satirical
alleviate the problem, so          journey. Once the reader
that blood is not spilled          dives in with him, there is
needlessly, but, as one            no turning back.
warrior says to B5's               Vonnegut's first-person
Commander Ivanova:                 narrator, John, sets out to
Rule changes” - deep sigh -        write The Day the World Ended.
“lost in committee.”               This is meant to be non-
Oh, yeah, I’ve been there.         fiction collection of "what
I was always one to volunteer      important Americans had done
for various subcommittees, as      on the day when the first
well - especially the ones         atomic bomb was dropped on
that needed a letter or            Hiroshima, Japan."
document written. This is a        His first encounter, by way
trap, by the way, that the         of correspondence, is with
unwary should avoid as much        the youngest son of Dr. Felix
as they can.                       Hoenikker. The elder
“Oh, you’re the writer,”           Hoenikker had  been the
someone will say sweetly when      leading scientist in the
passing the task off to the        creation of the A-Bomb.
poor sap who agrees to write       Next,  John meets Dr. Breed,
whatever  needs to be written.     who had also worked on
“The rest of us don’t have         developing the atomic bomb.
your way with words.”              Breed shares some history of
Now that you ego has been          Ilium, New York where much of
sufficiently poisoned, off         the research was done. Breed
you go to write the needed         tells of a man hanged in 1782
missive. After all, you are        for murdering 26 people.
The Writer.                        Breed says that the man sang
The trouble will begin once        on the scaffold. The
you have presented your            following conversation has
finished product to the            got to be the epitome of
committee.                         denial. John begins:
Suddenly everyone who wasn’t       "‘What was the song about?'
a writer the month before has      ‘You can find the words over
somehow become William             at the historical Society, if
Faulkner, and your prose is        you're really interested.' ‘I
submitted, line by line, word      just wondered about the
by word, to the fiercest           general tone.' ‘He wasn't
literary criticism one is          sorry about anything.' ‘Some
ever likely to encounter.          people are like that.' ‘Think
“Oh, I think this section          of it!' said Dr. Breed.
would have more impact if you      ‘Twenty-six people he had on
used these words . . .”            his conscience!' ‘The mind
“Are you sure you want to be       reels,' I said."
so direct? Maybe you could be      Vonnegut was a master of that
more subtle?”                      caliber of irony throughout
Or the ever-popular                Cat's Cradle. There are no
“How come you forgot to            sacred cows here. Vonnegut
mention this?” This being          nails just about every
something so trivial that          establishment in our culture;
most board members don’t even      he treats clerics, scientists,
know about it.                     educators, politicians and
By the time the “editing” is       just run-of-the mill
done, not only is your letter      blowhards with an even handed
or document something that         satiric walloping.
you don’t recognize but it         Breed plants the notion in
isn’t something that you           John that Hoenikker had been
would even claim to have           working on a formula, ice-
written when you were drunk.       nine, that could instantly
Finally, mistaking your            freeze all liquid matter. Its
glares for looks of intensify,     purpose would have been to
your fellow “writers” will         make it easier for armies to
all congratulate themselves -      get through mud.  As often
and you, of course (you did        happens in research, no
have a hand in it, after all)      thought was given to possible
on the finely crafted piece        consequences. Just because we
of drivel.                         are scientifically or
Next time, of course, one of       technologically able to do
them will volunteer to write       something doesn't necessarily
whatever document the              mean that it's a good idea to
committee/board needs. After       do it. John's quest now turns
all, we all got over this          to discovering if any of the
emotional hump. How hard can       formula is still in existence.
writing really be?                 More diabolical than germ
******                             warfare is ice-nine warfare.
Quote of the Day                   You freeze the seas, you
It’s a mistake to remake a         eradicate human existence.
great picture, because you         Cat's Cradle is about lies,
can never make it better.          the lies of institutions, the
Better you should find a           lies we pass off on one
picture that was done badly        another, and the lies we tell
and see what can be done to        ourselves.
improve it.  - Samuel Goldwyn      In his readers, Vonnegut has
*****                              the talent to produce tears
Cat’s Cradle                       while he induces laughter.
Humans are an odd breed. We        Oscar Wilde said that, "Life
are the only  species capable      is too important to be taken
of creating the exquisite          seriously." Kurt Vonnegut has
beauty of the Sistine Chapel       always understood exactly
in Rome, the Great Mosque in       what Wilde meant by that
Mecca and still be able to         statement.
wreak horrific death and           I really miss this guy.
destruction on one another. I      rsdrake@cox.net
think that it's healthy to         

Tags: , , , , ,

Related posts: