Judge rules that Sen. Peace recall election can go forward

The Nov. 8 recall election of      eventuality."
Senate President Russell           Pearce did not return calls
Pearce will go forward, at         for comment.
least for now.                     Last month, Gov. Jan Brewer
Maricopa County Superior           called a Nov. 8 election in
Court Judge Hugh Hegyi on          Mesa's Legislative District
Friday denied a legal              18 after Maricopa County
challenge of the recall            elections officials certified
petitions filed by Pearce's        that 10,365 of the 16,949
attorney Lisa Hauser. But          signatures submitted by
Hauser said she will appeal        Citizens for a Better Arizona
the ruling to the Arizona          were valid.
Supreme Court.                     The group needed at least 7,
If Hauser can get more than 2,     756 for the recall to qualify
609 of the 10,365 certified        for the ballot.
signatures thrown out, the         Citizens for a Better Arizona
election would be canceled.        supporters have said they do
If she cannot, the state will      not believe Pearce reflects
see the first recall election      the goals of District 18.
of a state lawmaker in             They said residents want to
Arizona history.                   see their leaders bring more
Hauser's legal challenge           jobs and improve education
alleged several problems with      and health care, not push
the signatures, including          more legislation on illegal-
that none of the petition          immigration enforcement and
forms complied with state          loosening gun restrictions,
requirements that a petition       as Pearce has done.
gatherer sign an oath that         Attorney Thomas Ryan, who
the signatures are "genuine"       represented the recall group,
and that the recall statement      said Hegyi struck down all
was misleading and did not         eight of Hauser's allegations.
clearly explain that signing       "I'm pleased that the judge
the petition would support a       understood our arguments and
recall election.                   accepted them," he said,
"As the Supreme Court has          adding that he also likes his
stated, recall petitions are       chances with the Supreme
'not a judicial (proceeding)       Court.
but political in nature,' "        Group co-founder Randy Parraz
Hegyi wrote in his ruling.         called the appeal a sign of
"The voters may recall a           desperation.
public official for any            "They are trying to obstruct
reason or no reason at all."       the voters," he said. "This
Hauser, in an e-mailed             shows how far Pearce will go
statement, said the ruling         to undermine a legally
was expected.                      sanctioned election."
"As the court indicated in         Candidates interested in
the ruling there are several       running against Pearce in the
questions raised which             election have until Sept. 9
require the Supreme Court's        to collect the 621 signatures
review," she said. "We look        required to qualify for the
forward to our opportunity to      ballot and submit them to the
present our case to Arizona's      Secretary of State's Office.
highest court."                    So far, Mesa Republicans
Ed Phillips, communications        Jerry Lewis and Olivia Cortes,
director for Citizens Who          as well as independent Tommy
Oppose the Pearce Recall,          Cattey, have filed paperwork
said the Supreme Court could       to begin collecting
hear the case by the end of        signatures.
this month.                        Cattey has since announced he
"We'll hope for the best," he      will not run.
said. "We're prepared for any      

Tags: , , , , , ,

Related posts: